White Dwarf July 2013 Review – Apocalypse

The July White Dwarf was in my eyes the best White Dwarf for a long time. And by that I don’t mean there hasn’t been a good one for a long time, last month’s was good. I mean I can’t recall the last time I read every page without having to force myself. I will add this site is 40k only so an issue which is 90% 40k will always get a good review.

white dwarf review

New releases


It’s all 40k releases and there is 50 pages to cover them. For me the highlight is the new Necron Super heavy, not the Chaos Lord of Battle on the cover.

Necron super heavy

The pictures are clear the, models look good and the prices are high. GW have continued to hike the price of the new models. The new super heavies are 35% more expensive than the old ones, but we can’t hold that against White Dwarf.

There are two new plastic kits, the re-boxed Baneblade/Shadowsword, 4 new space marine captains, 3 new fortifications and of course Apocalypse. You can read all about these on the Games Workshop website.

 

Army of the Month

This month’s is a huge Chaos Warrior army and that appears to be enough Warhammer for this issue. Well there is a necromancer in the hall of fame.

Hobbit

The cover claims there is a hobbit in there but it’s obviously hiding too well. There are two new models

 

Writer’s Coulombs

Jervis Johnson writes about how much he enjoyed creating Apocalypse second edition. It’s a good read and nice to have him back on more tangible topics. I did get the impression he would have liked to have explained more about Apocalypse but either wasn’t able to or didn’t have space to.

Blanchitsu is missing. There is no explanation as to what happened to it.

Jeremy Vetock continues on from Jervis and writes about playing and organising large games. He makes reference to what Jervis did and didn’t write about. I don’t know if this means he waits for Jervis to draft his content and then picks from the remains, or it they sat down and planned what each would write about, the later being a bit more likely given Jervis’ dislike of hitting deadlines.

Tyranids

Battle Report

Dark Angels and Blood Angels with some support defend a Imperial defence line against Chaos and Necrons. This report was even better than last month’s. I managed to not see the outcome in advance. Fortunately it was in the normal place so I knew where not to look. There are extra fold out pages in this issue which were used to show the deployment map. Is someone at the Studio reading my suggestions?  Again these armies belonged to the staff, not the  studio, although I think that some of the super heavies where studios models.

This battle report has been written in four full turns and has lots of full table pictures. It’s the easiest battle report to follow yet. However be warned the outcome is still in BIG LETTERS on the last page. The only thing that isn’t clear is what the victory point tally was. The system they used is explained  at the beginning, it had something to do with super heavies and defence points, but by the time I had reached the end I’d forgotten it.

 

Paint Splatter

The six page painting guides cover most of the new releases, buildings included. All good stuff.

Parade Ground

There were lots of different units in parade ground, lots of Space Marines and Xeons, again really good content.

From the studio

Great explanations from the writers of Apocalyse. I’ve held off ordering Apocalypse this month and used the money for a Games Day ticket. From what is said about Apolcalyse in the issue, it sounds like the studio done more than given is a fresh coat of paint. It doesn’t sound like anything has been done to stream line the rules and make it play any faster.

Apocalypse

Summary

Over all 9/10

I’d have given it 10 if there was more content for other systems and more information about what the changes in Apocalypse are.

Ben

GW motion for Chapterhouse studios to pay legal costs of $225k

The motions for final judgements have been raised by both Games Workshop and Chapterhouse Studios.

Games Workshop have requested that Chapterhouse Studios pay a further $225,000 in legal costs. Citing GW’s own victory on the majority of claims; which they did voluntarily not drop. GW have not appealed the verdict.

Chapter house have countered than GW should pick up their own legal costs, as GW did not win the majority of claims raised at the start of trial. Chapterhouse have not appealed the $25k fine.

This document contains the motions for final judgements and a list of the juries findings, listing the claims witch were and were not granted.

401-main

 

ChapterHouse Studios vs Games Workshop – Outcome

Judgement awarded to GamesWorkshop on 35 counts

The jury has given their verdict on ChapterHouse’s use of alleged Games Workshop trademarks. Belloflostsouls.net have posted the following information.

Initial notes:
This is a Jury Verdict, not a Final Judgement

Break down of the counts:

Copyright Claims
160 claims alleged against ChapterHouse Studios
power clawGamesWorkshop won on a third, including  ChapterHouse Studios Powerfists

mk1 shoulderpadChapterHouse Studios won on two thrids of the claims, including using the  shape and size of GamesWorkshop shoulder pads.

General Trademark Claims
Nine claims were alleged against ChapterHouse Studios
ChapterHouse Studios won all 9 claims, including either no infringement, or fair use of the GamesWorkshop trademarks on ChapterHouse Studios website.

Disputed Trademark Claims
There were tweenty one disputed trademark claims alleged against ChapterHouse Studios
ChapterHouse Studios won 11 claims
GamesWorkshop won 10 claims

GW Trademarks ruled “Previously Used in Commerce” Claims
61 claims alleged against ChapterHouse Studios
ChapterHouse Studios won 35 claims
GW won 27

Notable Trends and Individual Products Under Dispute
ChapterHouse Studios lost on some individual products including:
-Doomseer
-Dark Elf Arch Tortures

doomseerDark Elf Arch Torturess

These products will have to be withdrawn from sale.

ChapterHouse Studios won on some individual products including:
-Jetbike
-Super-heavy walker model
-Lizard Ogre

Chapterhouse jETBIKELizard-ogre

Damages Awarded:
ChapterHouse Studios ordered to pay GW damages of $25,000 USD

While it may appear that ChapterHouse Studios have won on the majority of claims, there has been no ruling on who is picking up the legal costs. If both sides pick up their own cost GW will walk away with a much bigger bill then CHS as Chapter Houses’ representation was working pro bono. If CHS have to pick up GW costs it hard to see how ChapterHouse will be able to keep operating.

The winner from this case is the hobbiest. It is now possible for third parties in America to manufacture kits compatible with the Warhammer universe. However if CHS have to pick up the legal bill it’s unlikely anyone would choose to. Full details on where the court has drawn the line won’t been known until more details of the trail have been released.

Those that wish to buy any of the products under dispute may have now missed their opportunity.

The final judgement will probably come next week.

Ben

Games Workshop Price Increase 2013

Ultramarine Army

It’s that time of year when the community is normally having big debate over weather Games Workshop’s price increase was fair and who has been impacted the worst. Instead the community is in a stunned silence. With the exception of Eldar Dire Avengers, only paints and and brushes have had a price increase. Or so it seems, yet when I walked around my local store last weekend I was still shocked at the prices. The ones that caught my attention?

The Eldar Wraith fighter which costs almost twice as much as the Dark Elder Razorwing. Can you see why? I can’t.

Twice an much as a Razorwing

 

The Eldar Wraith Knight which costs as much as a Stompa or Baneblade but comes in a box 1/2 the size, with a lot less plastic in it.

In fact the Landraider’s frame requires  a bigger box.

Wraith knight needs a tiny boxLandradier more plastic than an Wraithknight

While making stealth price raises on new kits, Games workshop have dropped the price of some models this month.

Eldar, Chaos and Space Marine bikes and jetbikes have all come down in price along with Necron Distroyers and Eldar Warwalkers.

The big question is what are GW up to? Does this show a change in their pricing strategy, could the exit of the CEO herald a new era of fairer pricing. Have Games Workshop realised they have made the hobby so expensive that new players are put off? Will these price drops be the start of GW making the hobby more appealing, or is this merely Games Workshop continuing to charge as much as possible for it’s products; adjusting the prices of lines that aren’t selling to the maximum we will pay?

There is only one thing I am certain of. If we go out on mass and buy the Wraith Knight there will be more products released at this price mark. If we top up our bike collections GW may re-box more of the current range in cheaper sets.

The choice is always ours. To buy or to buy something else.

Ben

Video of new 2013 Eldar models inc Wraithknight

While the size of the wraith knight is amazing, the Illic Nightspear and new Farseer strike me as the best sculpts in this release. It surprises me there are only 3 finecast models in this entire release. GW really are pushing their plastic lines.

The new Eldar release is certainly pushing a few boundaries. It’s a very long time since GW did a single model of the Wraithknight size or cost. The Dire Avengers have almost doubled in price. I can only hope that means they have double in usefulness. The new Wraithguard models are a great improvement.

GW do appear to have abandoned releasing units at the £20 price point, other that single units and recycled units. I hope they know what they are doing.